The Catholic Accent Podcast dives into the moments in Scripture that left everyone stunned — from miraculous healings to bold acts of faith that changed history. Hosted by Jordan Whiteko with Father Andrew Hamilton and Father Christopher Pujol, each episode unpacks the wonder of God’s work in a way that’s real, relatable, and just a little unexpected.
This isn’t your average Bible study — it’s faith with personality. You’ll laugh, learn, and maybe even see yourself in the disciples who were constantly surprised by what God could do. Whether it’s the storms, the sermons, or the stunning transformations, these conversations show that the same Spirit that moved the early Church is still moving today.
🎧 Listen, follow, and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
If a consecrated Host visibly became human flesh, would that change your mind or just raise more questions? We take on Eucharistic miracles with Father Ralph Wyman, digging into what the Catholic Church actually means by “miracle,” why faith involves more than what we can measure, and how claims like these are tested rather than casually accepted. Along the way, we connect the dots between the visible world and the invisible reality Christians say is just as real, even when it can’t be seen.
We spend time with one of the most famous accounts, the Eucharistic miracle of Lanciano in Italy, where a priest struggling with doubt reportedly witnesses a dramatic sign at the words of consecration. That story opens a deeper conversation about the Catholic Mass as sacrifice, not just a community meal, and about transubstantiation and the Real Presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist. We also explain why the Church often brings in scientific and medical experts, including skeptical voices, to investigate physical evidence and rule out easy explanations.
Then we bring it home. Even if you never visit a shrine, we still have tabernacles, chapels, and parishes where Catholics believe Christ is truly present right now. Eucharistic miracles, at their best, don’t replace faith, they invite a renewal of reverence, gratitude, and worship, and they point back to a core dogma clarified in the wake of the Reformation at the Council of Trent. If you’re curious about Catholic doctrine, Eucharistic devotion, and why these stories continue to unsettle modern assumptions, you’ll find plenty to wrestle with here.
Subscribe for more, share this with a friend who has questions, and leave us a review so more people can find the show. What part of Eucharistic belief do you find hardest to accept or most compelling?
Season three of the Catholic Accent Podcast is presented by St. Vincent College and La Trobe PA. Rooted in Catholic and Benedictine values, St. Vincent College helps students embrace the experience, discover their calling, and become the best version of themselves. Visit St. Vincent.edu to learn more. You're listening to the Catholic Accent Podcast, where we revisit the stories you thought you knew and answer the questions you've always had about faith. Season three, one take. Oh cut down your editing. God love you, editing. I'm your host, Jordan Wyko, along with Father Christopher Poogil and Father Andrew Hamilton. This episode, we're doing Eucharistic Miracles. Are they real or too hard to believe? And this episode, we're joined by Father Ralph Wyman.
SPEAKER_03
Thanks for having me.
Jordan
And it's a great joy to have you with us today, Father. And uh I met Father about a year ago now, when Bishop and I were in Rome for our pilgrimage. And um, so we've been able to stay in touch and become good friends. And the last visit to Rome, I made sure to stop and see Father, and he um has a very interesting work. Why don't you tell us a little bit about yourself?
SPEAKER_03
I'm a simple priest, you know, very simple. I serve as a professor here in Rome um for theology and bioethics and morals, and I work as a military chaplain to German Dammed Forces.
Jordan
And you're at the Vatican?
SPEAKER_03
Yes.
Jordan
And Father, you're also um one of the founding members of the Benedict Society, yes, that's true.
of the Ratzinger Schüler Chris, so that's a former student of Pope Benedict and a few other things, but it's not so important, perhaps.
Jordan
So, quick overview of today's episode. We're talking about Eucharistic miracles, which are reported events in which the consecrated host visibly changes in ways that defy normal explanation. So they often are uh appearing as flesh or blood, and these events have been recorded across centuries in places like Italy, uh, Argentina, you know, all over. Um and the church investigates these claims carefully and then inv often involving medical and scientific analysis before recognizing them as worthy of belief or devotion. So why don't we talk about it?
SPEAKER_03
Oh yes, you you asked the the basic question at the very beginning whether it is hard to believe. I mean, first you have to cover what is faith. So and here you find a very good answer in the letter of the Hebrews, chapter 11, verse 1. Faith is the realization of what is hoped for and evidence of things not seen. So there's the invisible world, there's the world of God, and this is a very powerful part of reality. So once again, things not seen, but they are real. So when we talk about miracles, we talk about God intervening, he surpasses the human faculties and the human capacities, and only he can operate miracles. So we can make things appear like miracles, but only he can operate miracles. So that's what we're talking about. So we we talk about the Eucharist as such, we're always talking about a miracle. And then, of course, there are many, as you mentioned at the introduction, there are many miracles that have happened, especially here in Italy where I live right now.
You know, Eucharistic miracles, like they're considered signs, right? Like to pointed towards a deeper truth or telling you.
Fr. Hamilton
Yeah, there's a lot of attacks around the reality of the Eucharist, right? As the sense of Catholic faith, without the Eucharist, like what would we really be? Like, where's the communion even gathered around in that sense? Is Jesus our corporate head together? And so over generations, there's always kind of an attack upon like the divinity of Christ and then other teachings of the church. And so Eucharistic miracles, if nothing else, really back up what the Catholic Church has professed as one of its principled uh realities, and that often to people I think beyond the church can sound almost ridiculous to them, maybe in a way. Right, to say that this what seems like invisibility piece of bread actually has a reality that that's present there to them that maybe, as as Father mentioned, you know, we we profess a lot of things about the visible and the invisible. And that people, when they see that break into reality in time and space for them, it kind of blows up their entire worldview that now opens up this entire chasm of exploration of what they didn't even know was there.
Jordan
And the beauty of Eucharistic miracles, I think, point us back to the sacrificial reality that the Eucharist is. It's not simply just a, you know, the old agape meal or a uh a nice dinner where we come around the table as so often we see in today's um ecclesial climate, where things have become easier to understand rather than taking into account the Eucharistic sacrifice that the Mass is to begin with. So, Father, could you talk to us a little bit about the Mass as that sacrificial reality that the Eucharist is uh, you know, truly the sac Christ is the sacrificial
Yes, I can try to. So, and we may start just with mentioning one example, a miracle this has happened, because in the miracles, things become visible that are usually unvisible to us. So, one of the most famous miracles, Eucharistic miracles, this has happened, happened in Italy in Lanciano, in round about 750. It's the oldest and the most renowned Eucharistic miracle. According to tradition and to what we know about that time period, a Basilian monk and priest was struggling with doubts about the Holy Eucharist. So he was not really sure whether the transformation, the substance changes really. So he was he was not really sure about this. Nevertheless, he continued to celebrate Mass. As we know, all the sacraments are sacraments of faith. So they require faith to be fully understood, yet they remain effective ex operato through the power of God Himself. So one day, while celebrating Mass and wrestling inwardly with these doubts, the monk reached the words of consecration. So that's the crucial point. The moment of transubstantiation, when Catholics, when we believe that the substance of bread and wine becomes the real presence of Christ. At that very moment, the bread and wine were said to have transformed visibly into human flesh and blood. Those present, you can imagine this, people being present at that mass, those present witnessed the priest's astonishment. And news of the event quickly spread throughout the monastery and the surrounding region. Soon afterwards, the blood it corrugated into five distinct parts, which many associate with the five wounds of Christ. So the flesh and blood were preserved. The event was investigated, and the church later proclaimed it a miracle. So the relics were then placed in a special place where they remain on display in Lanchano to this day. And now the miracle continues to attract attention because of scientific studies conducted in the 70s and 80s. Medical researchers concluded that the relics consist of genuine human heart, tissue, and blood with no trace of preservatives, yet they have remained intact over the centuries. So the blood type was identified as AB, the same type associated with the shroud of Turin. So you can see here already how all the Eucharistic miracles are interrelated. They express what we really celebrate. God becomes present under the species of bread and wine. He's truly present. And that's what's happening in the Eucharism for that reason. It's not just a banquet, it's participating in the very moment of our salvation. You are staying under the cross and you're participating in this event of our salvation whenever you participate in the Holy Eucharist.
Like, how do they investigate something like this?
Fr. Hamilton
It would be easy for the church to just say this is true because it backs up kind of already like what we're saying, right? So you want to bring in other people that would even be skeptical of that reality to give a whole entire analysis. So you would have people that would be considered more secular scientists or doctors and so forth to look at it to get an outside perspective. Of course, just because you have faith and believe in the Catholic faith wouldn't make you not a great doctor or an analysis in that way. It's just people could say that maybe there's a conflict of interest because you would have a wish fulfillment of wanting that thing to be true. So you try to guard against, I think, easy ways of trying to knock down miracles or these other things that we have, like the Shroud of Turn and so forth. So opening up that to widespread analysis and criticism and then still not having natural explanations for the Eucharistic miracle, say, for example, in Lanciano, Italy, then starts to build a cumulative case to say if no one's understanding this across all of these different areas of study and scientific inquiry, now we really have something that puzzles the mind and maybe posits that it's God's divine working rather than something that's just purely natural.
Jordan
So, Father uh Ralph Wyman, what what is the process to Yeah, it depends.
SPEAKER_03
So, for example, the same happens when the miracle occurs at Lourdes, for example, right? The Merrion Pilgrimage Place. So then usually there are scientists involved who are not Catholics. So that's one criterion, usually, because um they want a perspective from outside, but they have to be real scientists, so people who are really experts, and so then they start investigating. So the Eucharistic miracle in Anchanner, for example, is very well investigated. So they have done research on the tissues and they have figured out that this is uh a tissue from a human heart, from the heart muscles, and the blood group or blood type was identified, as I've just said, as AB. So and it's very interesting. So all these details are investigated, and you have no scientific explanation whatsoever. So the findings, the scientific findings, um, they they prove that this is a miracle. Also, that they did not corrupt. Imagine this is this is human flesh. So it did not corrupt within 1,200 years, which is in itself already a miracle. So you can see there's a lot of evidence, but if you still do not want to believe it, you will not. So God always respects our freedom. And um, nevertheless, these miracles do exist, and people go there, and when they do a pilgrimage to these places, they come back to their diocese to their places with a refreshed faith in what we really believe. Because what we believe in the Eucharist is not an invention, it's not what we made up, it is a reality, but an invisible
So, what should people actually take away from these miracles in their daily life? Well, first I think it's based on faith. We have to make assent to the truth, and we have to accept faith uh what it is.
Fr. Hamilton
But it's it's a response to the graciousness in the working of God. Like I'm thinking even with the just recent publication of the first encyclical of Pope Leo, this sense of transhumanism, or say, like the Tower of Babel, of building things up to God, like as a mechanism by which we're trying to reach beyond ourselves. This is something that there's a descent down from God to then work amongst us to show us. It's not that we have to do something great, but rather this is a gift of God, and so is faith in like the religion itself. There's this great contrast between those that have faith that can see to believe, and those that have been clouded over maybe by a lot of our modern technologies, realities, and so forth, that it becomes hard for them to see beyond to what like is just present to them, sitting right there. Think about how great that would be in the United States. We don't have Eucharistic miracles, we don't even have a lot of these ancient buildings.
Jordan
But even with what we do have, we still have the true presence of God in our tabernacles. And are there people in there praying? Are people genuflecting? And even on that level, I think we have to recover that sense of the sacred in what we do have. The Eucharistic miracles, you know, for us, I think in the States, we can travel on pilgrimage and go and and pray and seek God in these in these ways that He's made Himself known to us, but we can't forget that here and now we have the presence of God in our churches, in our chapels as well.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, I would recommend that we have to rediscover the holiness and the greatness of this sacrament. And uh I mentioned that before, Saint Thomas called the Eucharist the sacrament of sacraments, so it's the greatest gift. God is truly present in the Holy Eucharist under the species of bread and wine. But in order to approach him, we have to have faith. Because in every holy mass, he is truly present, but it is through faith that I encounter him. So this understanding is echoed actually in the testimony of Padre Pio. He is so well known all over the world and venerated. He had expressed this in striking terms. He said, It would be easier for the world to exist without the sun than without the holy mass. Imagine this. It would be easier for the world to exist without the sun than without the holy mass. For the sun is only a creature, whereas the Eucharist is God Himself among us. And therefore, I think we must learn once again to broaden our horizon and recognize this greatness of all gifts that God offers us in the Holy Eucharist. At the same time, this awareness calls us to receive and adore the Eucharist with deep reverence, love, and respect.
Jordan
So Eucharistic miracles don't replace faith in the Eucharist. It invites us to see it. It should enhance faith deeper. It invites us to see more deeply into what's already there. Is that what the takeaway is?
SPEAKER_03
Yes, they are an invitation, an invitation to renew our faith in the Holy Eucharist and to approach the Blessed Sacrament with greater reverence, devotion, and gratitude. So that's what they are, and for that reason, God permits and operates these miracles. And for many Catholics, these miracles are reminders also that Christ remains truly present in the Eucharist, continually offering Himself for the spiritual nourishment and salvation of souls. So for that reason. And so it's confirms us and it confirms also what the church teaches, because we are here talking about a dogma of the church. Here we're not talking about a pious opinion. So the real presence of our Lord Jesus Christ was and is a dogma of the church, and it was defined the Council
Which is just father for context for people outside that wouldn't know about the Council of Trent, which is in response to the different breaking off of groups within the Protestant, we call it Reformation usually, but like revolution of breaking away from the church and really denying the true presence. Yeah, dogmatic statements of the church already, and the importance of the church in the world, its sacraments and so forth down the line. Like so, the importance of the sacrament of the sacraments, a visible sign of an invisible reality instituted by Christ and given to his church for salvation. That's the important part of the entire Christian faith, the invisible becoming visible, the incarnation separating Christianity from other religions, the word becoming flesh. And the importance of that, especially in understanding the unique power of Christianity in culture and history and how it changes the world. A lot of our ethics, our values, everything that we hold, and things that we even hold to be reprehensible are through a Christian ethos and lens. I think finding Eucharistic miracles beyond helping people just to believe in the church and the sacrament of the sacraments of the church also helps people to look back into Christian history and past to then see the development of what Christianity has accomplished in the world and what we take for granted every day.
Thanks for listening to the Catholic Accent Podcast.
Jordan
Don't forget to follow, like, and subscribe to our show, share with your friends, and leave a question at the accentonmine.org slash the Catholic Accent Podcast. But yeah, I mean the ascension. I'm good with men of Galilee. Hopefully you were okay with being on the podcast after hearing what it was. The wild west. Yeah, pretty much.