The Catholic Accent Podcast
The Catholic Accent Podcast dives into the moments in Scripture that left everyone stunned — from miraculous healings to bold acts of faith that changed history. Hosted by Jordan Whiteko with Father Andrew Hamilton and Father Christopher Pujol, each episode unpacks the wonder of God’s work in a way that’s real, relatable, and just a little unexpected.
This isn’t your average Bible study — it’s faith with personality. You’ll laugh, learn, and maybe even see yourself in the disciples who were constantly surprised by what God could do. Whether it’s the storms, the sermons, or the stunning transformations, these conversations show that the same Spirit that moved the early Church is still moving today.
🎧 Listen, follow, and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
🌐 TheAccentOnline.org/TheCatholicAccentPodcast
The Catholic Accent Podcast
BONUS 29 - "All Stories Are True, But Some Of Them Really Happened." (Feat: Fr. Francisco Whittaker)
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
We revisit why parables can be deeply true even when they are not literal history, and how that kind of truth can reshape the way we see God and ourselves. We connect the prodigal son to the laborers in the vineyard to name envy, receive mercy, and keep running back to the Father.
• parables as vehicles of truth beyond material facts
• faith as supra-rational rather than anti-reason
• science and religion as complementary ways of knowing
• Tolkien as a clear example of “true” fiction
• resentment in the elder son and the all-day laborers
• God’s generosity and the challenge of envy
• heaven, reward, and why good deeds go with us
• practical takeaway to return to the Father for grace
Don't forget to follow, like, and subscribe to our show, share with your friends, and leave a question at TheAccentOnline.org/TheCatholicAccentPodcast
Visit TheAccentOnline.org
Subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or anywhere you listen to podcasts.
Follow us on YouTube
Ask a question or leave a voicemail.
Jordan Whiteko, Father Andrew Hamilton, Father Christopher Pujol, Cliff Gorski, John Zylka, Sarah Hartner, Luke Zylka
Welcome And One Take Setup
SPEAKER_01You're listening to the Catholic Acton podcast, where we revisit the stories you thought you knew and answer the questions you've always had about fate. Season three, one take. I'm gonna cut down your editing. I'm not gonna be able to use any of that. You can use all of this. 100%. I'm your host, Jordan Whiteco, along with Father Christopher Poojo and Father Andrew
What Makes A Story A Parable
SPEAKER_01Hamilton. So what makes this story a parable?
Fr. HamiltonWe don't know necessarily that it happened, but it still has truth to it. This is a very important point to make. This absolutely proves that not all truth is just only material or scientific truth. That I can tell you a story that maybe doesn't even have characters in it that existed in real time in history, and yet it can have a deep meaning metaphorically to you that then changes aspects
Faith And Reason Beyond Science
Fr. Hamiltonof your life. That's a powerful truth, which shows you that there are things beyond just the physical world, that there's also this reality of faith, which we always say, faith at its best is always supra rational. It's above reason. Reason can take us so far, and then we get into realms of faith, philosophy, theology, that's beyond just the scientific method. Not that there's a rebuke there from Catholicism, but rather we use science for what it can and what's properly situated for, and then faith what it's properly situated for. In Christianity, that doesn't do that. This is where we kind of get mocked, is they take faith and they make it infra-rational. It almost fights against reason and science itself. And then that's a really bad look, I think, for Christians, because some of the greatest advancements
Tolkien And Stories That Tell Truth
Fr. Hamiltonin science have been knowledge have been through the church itself.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think to your point, Father, that uh truth itself in its nature is a transcendental. So it is beyond that which is just natural and material. So that there can be stories that aren't necessarily real in their nature, uh, but that are still true because it truth is not tied to, like you said, the material or reality necessarily in what our experience of it. It's tied to that which is real, most certainly, but not always our experience. So sometimes that the best truth is in fact communicated in things that aren't obviously real or obviously quote unquote true. They didn't necessarily happen. So that, you know, we great stories of myth or fantasy, uh, you know, my my favorite book series of all time is The Lord of the Rings, uh, that uh Tolkien through that, you know, communicates so many truths in a story and in a place that never happened, but that you can see underneath it so many realities of the human experience and our relationship with one another and with God. So that, yeah, one of my favorite things to tell people is some stories are true, all stories are true, but some of them really happened, um, which is also the case with the parables of the Bible, you know, uh that Christ uses stories that aren't necessarily real, that the people have seen or heard, but because he's communicating something beyond them, which is the kingdom of heaven. So if he can't necessarily or doesn't, you know, just say to them, oh well, you saw this, you saw this, so that's what the kingdom is like. No, rather the kingdom of heaven is like something you haven't experienced.
Prodigal Son Meets Vineyard Resentment
SPEAKER_02There's also a connection I see between this parable and the parable of uh the labors in the vineyard. So the parable of the prodigal son is such a beloved parable, and I don't know many people who don't just think it's like their favorite, it's their favorite one. But one parable that whenever I've I talked to people about it or I preached about it last year, um, I had people come up to me like, oh, I just really don't like this, is where the parable of the owner of the vineyard goes out at different times of the day to bring laborers into his vineyard, and there's ones who come in and only work one hour and they receive the same wage. And the ones who have been there all day, like the elder son, expect now I'm gonna receive more. And they receive the same as the one who caught in at the 11th hour. And the owner of the vineyard says, Well, are you envious because I'm generous? And I think that's kind of where the resentment of maybe people in the church who have been cradle Catholic and they stayed Catholic their whole life. I've been working and laboring the church, or I've been faithful every Sunday. And here's someone who comes in, uh, and it seems like they're more on fire for the Holy Spirit after being away for so long. That's not fair. I should receive, right? I should have been rewarded.
SPEAKER_01Or we treat them just like I'm treated. I should leave
Heaven Rewards And God Remembers
SPEAKER_01special.
Fr. HamiltonRight. Yeah. Here's the good news, though, within the Catholic understanding of heaven and hierarchy is that heaven is not completely egalitarian.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, true.
Fr. HamiltonThe Blessed Virgin Mary holds a higher rank, more or less, or the angels are ranked in order and so forth. So those good things and good deeds that you do in the name of Christ Jesus in the state of grace, they go with you. They go with you. Your good deeds go with you, and there actually is a sense that you're being rewarded. Now, that initial salvation seems the same, right? But God is good in that he pours that out in his generosity. So, like every action that we do, it's not just like we're kind of squeaking by to get like the passing grade, then we're good. God will be able to do that. Yeah, God will remember all of the sacrifices that we made, and they will become and more or less like medals of honor for us into
Return To The Father And Closing
Fr. Hamiltonthe next life. What do you what do you think the main takeaway for people listening to this are?
SPEAKER_02Uh I guess no matter what either son that you identify with, or whether whatever place you are in, the father most certainly will receive you. Uh and ask for the grace to return to the father if you feel like you're in a place that they can't, or that maybe you're beyond it, or you're you're bitter about where your relationship as God has been, or there's something about the church that has turned you away. Uh that God is certainly much greater than our experience of Him could ever imagine. Uh so never stop running to the Father.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for listening to the Catholic Accent Podcast. Don't forget to follow, like, and subscribe to our show, share with your friends, and leave a question at the AccentOnline.org slash the Catholic Accent Podcast.