The Catholic Accent Podcast
The Catholic Accent Podcast dives into the moments in Scripture that left everyone stunned — from miraculous healings to bold acts of faith that changed history. Hosted by Jordan Whiteko with Father Andrew Hamilton and Father Christopher Pujol, each episode unpacks the wonder of God’s work in a way that’s real, relatable, and just a little unexpected.
This isn’t your average Bible study — it’s faith with personality. You’ll laugh, learn, and maybe even see yourself in the disciples who were constantly surprised by what God could do. Whether it’s the storms, the sermons, or the stunning transformations, these conversations show that the same Spirit that moved the early Church is still moving today.
🎧 Listen, follow, and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
🌐 TheAccentOnline.org/TheCatholicAccentPodcast
The Catholic Accent Podcast
BONUS 24 - The Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
We trace why temptation appears in Eden and why God’s love makes real choice unavoidable. We connect Genesis to the New Adam and New Eve, then follow the story all the way to the Cross as the true Tree of Life.
• why fallen angels matter for understanding the serpent in the garden
• free will before the fall and why omniscience does not erase choice
• concupiscence as the wound that changes how we desire and decide
• the Old Testament law as boundaries that cannot heal the heart
• Christ fulfilling the law through love, plus commission and omission
• Jesus as the New Adam and Mary as the New Eve in salvation history
• why the fruit is not called an apple and why fig shows up
• nakedness, shame, and a Theology of the Body lens on distortion
• the Tree of Life, protection after sin, and the Cross as fulfillment
Don’t forget to follow, like, and subscribe to our show, share with your friends, and leave a question at TheAccentOnline.org/TheCatholicAccentPodcast
Visit TheAccentOnline.org
Subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or anywhere you listen to podcasts.
Follow us on YouTube
Ask a question or leave a voicemail.
Jordan Whiteko, Father Andrew Hamilton, Father Christopher Pujol, Cliff Gorski, John Zylka, Sarah Hartner, Luke Zylka
Cold Open And Show Setup
Fr. PujolYou're listening to the Catholic Acting podcast, where we revisit the stories you thought you knew and answer the questions you've always had about faith.
JordanSeason three, one take. I'm gonna cut down your editing. God love you, editing. I'm your host, Jordan Whiteko, along with Father Christopher Pujol and Father Andrew Hamilton. Let's roll.
Why The Serpent Is In Eden
JordanSo why was why was the devil there? Why was he allowed into the garden? Why was the serpent there? Did the devil bring himself into this?
Fr. PujolNo, well, the great battle of heaven would have already had taken place. And so you have your fallen angels and you have the angels that remained faithful and devoted and worshiping God in heaven. And so those fallen angels had already, you know, come into um this reality that would tempt humanity, which we still deal with today, and we'll talk about in another episode.
Fr. HamiltonThe really good principle for understanding everything in Genesis is God creates with love, which necessitates free will. So he created in the beginning the heavens and the earth and even the spiritual beings, right? Which would just be the high, pure intellect, spiritual angels. And the angels are created to serve God, but they have an ability to choose. And so they some choose, or we would understand from different allegorical senses, one third of them choose against God.
Free Will Before Original Sin
JordanSo not to confuse people, Adam and Eve did have free will before eating the forbidden fruit.
Fr. HamiltonAnd that's how they were able to choose this sense too of determinism of like, I have no free will, this is fate, it's gonna happen no matter what, this, that, or whatever. Even if God is omniscient, he knows everything and he's all powerful, that doesn't mean in our own particular life we don't have free will. Nobody that exists on earth today doesn't choose things. We wake up in the morning, we choose what time to get up, we choose what to do.
JordanWhether to hit snooze, what to do.
Fr. HamiltonYeah. So our entire life is choices down the way, which make habits, right? The choices that we make towards the good or the bad become habitual. And then that determines if we're likely to make a certain choice down the line or not, to choose the good or to restrict ourselves from evil.
JordanSo are you saying, though, um basically God telling them not to eat from this tree was more about trust because they really already had some of that good and evil knowledge. If they had free will and they had to make choices whether to do this, whether to do that.
Fr. HamiltonYeah, they they have free will certainly to choose. What they don't have is what we call concupiscence that we're affected by. So that's the knowledge of sin or evil.
Fr. PujolSo like a child who's created And they also didn't have original sin.
Fr. HamiltonYeah. There's like a curiosity, a natural, healthy curiosity of like a child who hasn't experienced evil yet, isn't tainted by that. We all look at that and say, like, that's a beautiful thing that should be protected. And so that's how they were experiencing the world. But once they experience sin and all that rushes in, now sin kind of has a grip upon their hearts or their will to choose against God rather than for God. And one other thing with that, this is what we see in the Old Testament. The Old Testament, essentially in the Levitical laws, builds out 613 laws of a boundary. It's protecting the core of the law, the Ten Commandments, so that you don't fall into idolatry, these other things. But all it's healing is the behavior out here. It's just saying stay away from it and then you'll be healed. That's not enough. And that's why Christ comes in the New Testament and he says, Yes, that was important. There's truth and goodness in that. I came not to overthrow this, but rather to fulfill it, which is to say, no, all of this out here now needs to be rooted inside to say, like, no, the greatest part is loving God and loving neighbor and understanding I'm not just not doing this because I think it's an evil thing, but I have the purposes for why I'm actively, positively doing the good. Because that's what we say whenever we go into a confession, that we're asking forgiveness not only for the things that we have done, but that which we have not done for commission and omission. And saints get to the point of they're not committing sins in an active sense, but rather they're now actually taking responsibility for omitting doing the good in the world. And that's what transforms the world. So that's a good breakdown of kind of all salvation history there.
Fr. PujolAnd which is important to recognize also
The New Adam and The New Eve
Fr. Pujolthat that's why we call Christ Jesus is the new Adam because he's the re-foundation of humanity in the sense that he restores us to that perfect relationship with God. That chasm is no longer broken, but the the effects of Adam and Eve remain, which is what leads us to baptism in our whole sacramental system. And Eve, there's is replaced in the sense of by Mary, who becomes the new Eve. She is the perfect mother of the world, the mother of the church, in which children are baptized, where children receive grace, and then are able to go out into the world recognizing temptations exist, but never falling into them.
Fr. HamiltonOne of the great early church fathers, Saint Irenaeus of Lyon, he writes a treatise called Against the Heresies. So people that are believing false things about sacred scripture, the church, so on and so forth. And in there he writes that by a fallen angel, humanity falls. By an angel who gives the voice of God to a virgin, humanity rises, right? And so even within that, he he kind of expounds upon the idea that Eve was a virgin. She doesn't have children until after the fall.
Fr. PujolAnd what is she cursed with? Childbearing pangs and the struggles of motherhood and all of these things that we see in the world and we take for granted that this is just the way it is. But prior to the fall, that did not exist. Death did not exist, suffering did not exist.
Fr. HamiltonAnd this is why, like kind of the virginity of the Blessed Virgin Mary, as really upheld within the Catholic and Orthodox tradition, seems to absolutely be right because there's this whole restoration. From the beginning, what was lost is restored in the same way, but better. And so with Mary being a virgin, it imitates what Eve was virgin. Mary becoming the mother of the church is Eve the mother of creation. And so there's this balance between the two parts of sacred scripture.
Children Eat Their Fruit
JordanYou mentioned uh children, you know, and they said they're the first humans, so they're God's children, they basically are children, they don't have the knowledge that they will eventually once they eat that uh fruit. But I know that when I learned about it, um, it was kind of taught to us as a children's story where it was don't eat this apple, but apples never mentioned.
Fr. PujolYeah, and it's probably more of a fig or a pomegranate in reality of that whole region of the world. The nectar of the gods.
Fr. HamiltonWell, in terms of there's the ambrosia, right? The stories of like ancient Greece and so forth, or there's Prometheus bringing the fire from the gods. But Jesus goes into Jerusalem in the last week of his life and he curses a fig tree. And then coming back out of Jerusalem, there Peter recognizes says, like, Lord, look at the tree that you cursed, like there are no figs on it. And Jesus said, like, may no one ever eat of you again. There's some kind of illusion again.
JordanAs in going the whole way back to Adam in your garden. Okay. Yeah. Now, would the apostles have known this story prior to like was go ahead.
Fr. PujolYeah, the Jewish people would have known this story. It their true story of creation, and and it would have been taught at temple and synagogue.
Fr. HamiltonYeah, um
Fig Leaves And Disordered Desire
Fr. Hamiltoneven the fig as the fruit comes from a lot of the old, like ancient Jewish literature of what the rabbis were teaching. So that's why we can discover a lot about what Jesus would have understood about the story of Adam and Eve, because this is what he would have been brought up on as the general understanding of his religious experience. So the Torah and young boys being able to read that, what we now know as a bar mitzvah, and entry into the maturity of manhood was all about the first five books of what we know as the Old Testament, being the, or we call in the Greek Pentateuch, the five books, right? So Genetus, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy, originally believed and still by many scholars to be written by Moses or the closest followers of Moses and recorded in history for the Jewish people and their knowledge of their history and past.
Fr. PujolBecause the whole story of Adam and Eve also sets up the sacrificial rituals of the Jewish people who are trying to restore a relationship with God that they've lost. And so we see them offering bulls and bullocks and turtle doves, and they offer this bloody worship by, you know, splitting them in half, burning them on the altar. But none of that is enough to restore the relationship between God and man that was lost by the fall of Adam and Eve.
Fr. HamiltonSo even in the Genesis story before the fall, there's a sense that there's even a greater glory than this original holiness, which we get to later in the life of the church, after there's a fall into sin, there's a restoration of holiness that was in the beginning, but now it's even greater through Christ, because like we've seen the incarnate God directly face to face. Like the apostles knew Jesus in the broad daylight of seeing him and seeing his miracles in reality. And in heaven, we will see God fully for who he is as we are fully known. The other thing that they do immediately after their eyes are opened is they recognize their insecurity and their nakedness and they cover themselves up. Both Father Chris and I have fig trees that we keep. And the fig trees, if you look at the leaves, they're rather large, like as they even on smaller trees bloom out. So they would be a good covering in a way.
Fr. PujolAnd I'd like to take this opportunity to thank Bishop Kulik and Father Andrew here for taking care of my fig trees while I'm at school. We haven't killed them yet, thankfully. So but they get the fruits, they're not cursed.
Fr. HamiltonYeah. But in terms of like that fig tree leaf, it would kind of make sense to like cover oneself over. And the things that are covered over, like whenever we think about like the human body, this is a little theology of the body from John Paul II, is well, kind of the genitals, right? In the sense of like what we have in creation to generate, which is what will be the charge of God, which is to go out and populate the world to basically raise up souls for God. And the other parts being like that would be over like the breasts of a woman, the bosom that is like the nursing sense of like a mother. How much that's been co-opted towards like really vulgar ways of understanding the world, right? That's the problem with other things like um pornography and all these other things. It takes something that is meant to be holy and good and made by God, and then it perverts it towards something else. It corrupts it. It inverses it, which is what the devil does. He inverses the world constantly and makes it ugly rather than
Tree Of Life And The Cross
Fr. Hamiltonbeautiful. The only other thing I want to mention, too, is that there's two trees that are given specific names outside of all the other trees. The one, the knowledge of good and evil, not to be eaten of, and then there's another tree of eternal life. This is why I don't think that they would have lived forever had they been in the garden, because we don't get a recognition that they've eaten from the tree of eternal life yet. Now, after they sin, they disobey God, and now they're separated from God in a real way. There's a chasm there. If they would then go and eat from the tree of eternal life, and they would be separated God for eternity, we would call that hell. So God is a good father is not casting them forth from the garden as an angry dad who's just saying, get the heck out of here. He's rather trying to build a security or a protection for them until they're properly matured to then receive eternal life. And it's on a tree, and from the fruits of that tree would come eternal life. This is what makes sense of the whole entire reality of why God would send his only begotten son to be hung upon a tree, and that from his side springs forth the fruits that then bring us back into full communion with God in eternity, right? Which would be namely baptism, entry into the life of the church, and then blood being the Eucharist, literally the fruit from the tree that we receive. And if we eat of it, we have eternal life and we can see God again. We have that communion and connection with Him.
Closing Thoughts And Listener Prompt
Fr. PujolThat tree of eternal life really is the tree of the cross, the wood of the cross that brings us to eternal life.
JordanThanks for listening to the Catholic Accent Podcast. Don't forget to follow, like, and subscribe to our show, share with your friends, and leave a question at the Accentonline.org slash the Catholic Accent Podcast.
Button
JordanYou are free to eat from any tree in the garden, but you must not eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil. Why didn't they just go eat from the tree of eternal life before?
Fr. HamiltonStupid.